
Welcome to the stretch run. Take a seat, grab your tub of popcorn.
The flurry of moves ahead of the NFL trade deadline over the past two weeks set the stage for what is already shaping up to be a thrilling sprint to the finish, with the coveted 14 playoff spots very much still up for grabs.
Punches and counterpunches were thrown via iPhones and Androids pinging among front offices across the country by the Chicago Bears, Seattle Seahawks, Kansas City Chiefs, Buffalo Bills, and, of course, the Jacksonville Jaguars, among other contenders making moves that they believe better position themselves to make a deep run towards Los Angeles and the Super Bowl in 13 weeks.
However, very few — if any — of the general managers who took big swings would have even stepped to the plate had their rosters not been built around and thriving because of the elite level of play they’re getting from their homegrown franchise quarterback.
If Carson Wentz’s 8.9 passer rating against the Bills in Week 9 didn’t underscore the value of competent quarterback play, Tommy DeVito passing for 81 yards with one interception and one touchdown in relief of an injured Drake Maye against the Lions Sunday certainly belabored the point.
Does Ryan Poles flip two first-round picks and a fourth-round pick for Jeffery Simmons, if Caleb Williams didn’t have 1,020 passing yards with five touchdowns to one interception in four games before the trade?
Would James Gladstone have shipped a first-round pick, two second-round picks, and a fifth-round pick for Jordan Davis and Jessie Bates in a pair of blockbusters if Trevor Lawrence wasn’t powering the fifth-ranked offense by DVOA?
Is it even worth Brandon Beane trading for Amani Hooker if the Bills don’t have Josh Allen?
The answer to all of those questions is: probably not.
There is no tried-and-true formula for winning a Super Bowl, regardless of what anyone tells you.
Stifling defenses still travel in January.
Running backs absolutely matter in the swirling snow, freezing rain, and wind of playoff football.
An elite offensive line is pretty close to a prerequisite.
However, none of the equations work without dominant quarterback play being a key variable.
Of the 14 teams that began play Sunday projected to make the postseason, 10 of them have homegrown quarterbacks.
The quarterbacks currently slated to be in the postseason have combined to win seven MVP awards.
Then, there’s Jared Goff and J.J. McCarthy, two former first-round picks on their second teams.
Minnesota witnessed firsthand the perils of not having dominant quarterback play and was forced into trading a third-round pick for Kirk Cousins, or risk wasting a generationally dominant defense.
However, in public discourse and on social media, the debates built around what makes an elite quarterback or who qualifies as an elite quarterback has never been murkier; the conversations have never been more toxic.
We have reached a place societally where certain quarterbacks almost cannot be analyzed through the lens of traditional quarterback analysis without the analyst being accused of having ulterior motives or their character being called into question.
But, how do folks inside the league view quarterback play, and who do top executives, scouts, and coaches believe qualify as “elite”?
I set out to answer that question this weekend, asking a handful of league sources who they would select first if they were building their roster today, and why.
Here are their answers:
“I’m taking Josh Allen. He can do it all, and he seems tough as nails.” - NFL Offensive Coordinator
“Joe Burrow is the choice here, just because of his ability to make every throw from the pocket.” - NFL Head Coach
“The conversation starts with Patrick Mahomes; he’s just a winner, and always finds a way.” - NFL Offensive Coordinator
“Josh Allen. It’s not close. He has size, arm talent, and athletic ability. He’ll never be the most accurate, but I’ll take him, and I’ll win a bunch of games with him.” - NFL Offensive Coach
“If you start a team with Joe Burrow, you’ll do just fine.” - NFC South Personnel Executive
“I believe in three-year windows, and today, I’d take Josh Allen.” - AFC South Personnel Director
If it didn’t already feel apparent, it’s becoming more obvious that the AFC is going to be an absolute gauntlet between now and February.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
This column is an exclusive feature for our paid subscribers. Between The Hashmarks is completely independent NFL journalism. To unlock this entire article and receive every article sent directly to your inbox, consider supporting our work by becoming a paid or free subscriber today!
First Down: Kirk Cousins’ efficiency, Brian Flores’ mad brilliance, and the Vikings' New Ceiling
“You like that?!” - Kirk Cousins, October 25, 2015, Nolan Teasley, November 15, 2026 [probably].
There’s a lot of runway between here and the NFC Championship Game or the Super Bowl. But, the initial returns of Teasley’s trade to acquire Kirk Cousins from the Las Vegas Raiders Tuesday, in exchange for a third-round pick, looks like it has the potential to be a catalyst for a championship run.
Vikings 30, Packers 10 on Sunday at Lambeau certainly seemed to feature a Minnesota team with the potential to pillage its way to a title.
After all, Minnesota already boasted a championship-caliber defense, one that sacked Packers quarterback Jordan Love three times in the first half, at one point pressuring him on seven of eight dropbacks in the first 30 minutes.
This was a Packers offense that entered Sunday averaging 28.6 points per game over the past five weeks. Green Bay only reached Vikings territory five times Sunday, and the Packers turned it over on two of those trips.
Defensive Player of the Year frontrunner Dallas Turner sacked Love once and hit him twice.
When an errant third-down snap sailed over Love’s head with 12:17 remaining in the third quarter, it was Turner who recovered it. Five plays later, Will Reichard split the uprights to extend the Vikings’ lead to 20-0.
As the Vikings’ defense dominated, Cousins didn’t waste any time proving that he’s a significant upgrade from Wentz and Kyler Murray.
On 3rd down and 23 with 2:46 remaining in the first quarter, Cousins drilled wide receiver Myles Price on a deep slant, in traffic, for a 38-yard touchdown to extend the Vikings’ lead to 10-0.
By the end of the first half, the Vikings faced 3rd down and at least 15 three times, and Cousins was 2-for-2 on those snaps for 64 yards and a touchdown.
The Vikings weren’t getting that from their previous quarterback room.
Cousins appears to be the ultimate force multiplier for a defense that was beyond buoyed by his presence in his debut against the Packers.
Take, for example, the case of Harrison Smith.
Not only did Smith intercept Jordan Love in the end zone five seconds into the second quarter, but with 12:30 remaining in the half, he forced Love into a Levi Drake Rodriguez sack.
On the next snap, Smith sacked Love.
By the time the first-half horn sounded, the Vikings had sacked Love five times and intercepted him once.
Somehow, they were just getting started
When Love wasn’t being sacked, he was seeing marauding ghosts.
All told, Flores and the Vikings pressured Love on 60 percent of his dropbacks while forcing four takeaways that further tilted the game in Minnesota’s favor.
Love only completed 18 passes against the Vikings, who sacked or hit him 20 times.
ESPN Insights points out that Love has only been pressured on more than half of his dropbacks three times in his career, all of them this season, and two of those games came against Flores’ defense.
The Vikings’ eight sacks of Love are the most any defense has managed all season.
This is who the Vikings are, the tangible personification of Flores, and games like Sunday are true to the identity they’re forming in Minnesota.
“We talk about it every week,” Vikings linebacker Blake Cashman told me back in September. “Just the importance of disrupting the quarterback, getting him moved off his spot, throwing his timing off, which throws off the timing of routes. Even if you don’t get a sack, make the quarterback kind of step up, move out and have to reset his feet, that’s more time for the guys on the back end to get into coverage.”
Mission accomplished, against Love.
It isn’t just about swarming the quarterback, either, because Flores’ defense has now forced 13 turnovers this season, only the Packers and Buccaneers have created more.
Minnesota ultimately chased Love from the game, who was pulled for Tyrod Taylor with 3:20 remaining in the game, despite Love not stepping foot onto the field in the fourth quarter.
“You like that?!” - Brian Flores [probably].
This was a masterclass, and a mission statement all at once.
This was what the Vikings are capable of defensively and now what they aim to do with merely competent quarterback play as they improved to 7-2, with the sixth-most difficult remaining schedule in the league looming.
Cousins could prove to be the difference, not just after finishing 21-of-31 passing for 207 yards with two touchdowns and one interception.
Finishing with a 94.4 passer rating five days after arriving following a trade from the Las Vegas Raiders, and six days after Carson Wentz posted an 8.9 passer rating against the Bills shows the kind of instant impact an upgrade at quarterback can make.
However, the fact that Cousins’ presence helped the Vikings hold the ball 35:16 of Sunday’s game, allowing Flores’ defense to finally catch a blow on the sideline, with the benefit of fresh legs late, could prove invaluable.
This defense, which has now sacked the quarterback 37 times this season, has created 16 takeaways, and is holding opponents to just 11.6 points per game, doesn’t just travel; it imposes its will as the driving force of a team that legitimately now has to be thinking about rather than merely dreaming of a Super Bowl not far off on the horizon line.
Get the latest Between The Hashmarks Gear at our NEW Gear Shop, including our EXCLUSIVE ‘Kickers, Man …” T-shirt or hoodie with a portion of proceeds benefiting Hunger Free America!
Second Down: Lions Thrash Patriots in Munich, But Pay a Brutal Price
There might not be five players more dangerous in the open field than Detroit Lions running back Jahmyr Gibbs. Sunday in Munich, the New England Patriots found out the hard way in a 35-10 Lions thrashing.
Subscribe to our premium content to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
Upgrade- Save 26% OFF Forever, and Help Fight Hunger in America
- Every 4 Downs Column Each Monday, Access to Every Football Friday Mailbag, and Every Feature We Publish.

