Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images
Franchise quarterbacks hog the marquees and the banners lining city streets, the $40 million pass rushers steal the headlines and the hopes of opponents, and everyone knows their favorite team’s top receivers.
However, every roster built to win a championship or make a deep postseason run has players who might not always garner the attention, but their contributions often power the charge.
As the NFL’s stretch run heats up and contenders separate themselves from pretenders, the margin between a first-round exit and a trip to Los Angeles in February often comes down to the players opposing coordinators aren't circling in their Tuesday staff meetings just yet.
Whether it’s a nickel cornerback wreaking havoc on exotic blitzes in Denver, a tight end finally stepping out of a future Hall of Famer’s shadow after making his way 202 miles North to New York, or a wave of rookies instantly transforming playoff hopefuls in Kansas City, Chicago, and Cleveland, the league's most dangerous teams are getting massive production from unexpected places.
Here’s a look at the breakout stars and unheralded contributors who are fueling their team’s dash to the NFL Playoffs …
Ja'Quan McMillian, CB, Denver Broncos
It’s easy to lose track of Ja’Quan McMillian on a defense built around former Defensive Player of the Year Patrick Surtain, and thumpers like Alex Singleton, Nik Bonitto, Zach Allen, and Talanoa Hufanga, but quarterbacks are learning the hard way why that’s so dangerous.
McMillian made one of the most vitally important plays of the Broncos’ postseason when he intercepted Bills quarterback Josh Allen in a pivotal juncture of Denver’s AFC Divisional Playoff victory and has more than picked up where he left off amid a torrid start to the 2026 campaign.
Through the Broncos’ first nine games, McMillian has been a, somehow, underrated but significant driving force behind the Broncos’ dash to the top of the AFC West standings.
At 5-foot-9 and 183 pounds, McMillian is holding opposing quarterbacks to a meager 80.4 passer rating when throwing his direction, but Broncos defensive coordinator Vance Joseph is currently throwing him at opposing quarterbacks on exotic blitz packages where he’s fourth among cornerbacks with six pressures and leads the position with three sacks.
A versatile difference maker, McMillian has become just as valuable as a chess piece that offenses must account for on every play as he is consistently dominant in coverage for one of the league’s stingiest defenses.
If the Broncos are going to hold off the Chiefs in the division, much less survive a postseason gauntlet that includes potential matchups against Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, and Trevor Lawrence along the way, McMillian’s going to be a big part of the reason why.
Emmett Johnson, RB, Kansas City Chiefs
The Kansas City Chiefs didn’t just buy Patrick Mahomes a sledgehammer this offseason when they signed Kenneth Walker, they took dynamite to their entire identity when they doubled down on committing to the run by pairing him with fifth-round rookie Emmett Johnson.
This 2.0 version of the Reid-Mahomesian Chiefs dynasty may be the most dangerous yet because of Kansas City’s ability to grind defenses into dust on the ground as a force multiplier to the damage Mahomes is able to inflict as a freelancing creator and from the pocket as well.
When Walker was sidelined groin injury in Week 10, the Chiefs didn’t just proceed without missing a beat against the Falcons, but Johnson rushed for a season-high 101 yards, giving Reid and Kansas City pause about possibly resting Walker in Week 11 against the Cardinals ahead of a short week leading into Thanksgiving night against the Bills.
NFL legend LeSean McCoy is a big fan of what Johnson has been able to do, so far.
“I can see why Andy Reid compared us,” McCoy tells Between The Hashmarks.
Johnson is averaging a whopping 4.06 yards after contact, according to Pro Football Focus, and while he’s only logged 48 carries so far in his rookie season, six of them have been explosive runs of 10 yards or more.
However, where Johnson has made the most significant impact is as a pass catcher out of the backfield, as the Chiefs continue trying to navigate finding a reliable receiving corps.
Through nine games, Johnson has caught 20 passes on his 99 routes run for 307 yards and three touchdowns, while forcing 13 missed tackles in the open field.
Don’t be surprised if even after Walker gets healthy, that the Chiefs backfield morphs into more of a timeshare situation that likely won’t just keep both backs fresh and healthy but could be the cheat code to Kansas City’s offense powering a lengthy postseason run.
Love the outdoors. Keep in touch with who you love.

An early start at the lake. A quiet campsite. One more hour waiting for the perfect light. The things you love can take you beyond cell coverage.
With the ZOLEO Satellite Communicator, you can send an “I’m OK” check-in message, share your location, and message loved ones through its companion app. Enjoy the moment, and give the people who care about you a way to be part of it.
Save 20% on a regularly priced ZOLEO Satellite Communicator with code KEEPINTOUCH20.
Not valid on sale-priced devices or with other discounts. Valid outside promotional sale periods.
Isaiah Likely, TE, New York Giants
John Harbaugh is getting the version of Isaiah Likely that the Ravens hoped he would become all along while trying to emerge from Mark Andrews’ shadow in Baltimore.
Likely isn’t just playing like one of the premier pass-catching tight ends in the league this season, he’s vaulted into essentially the WR2 role alongside Malik Nabers in the Giants’ passing game.
It hasn’t mattered whether it’s been Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston, or J.J. McCarthy behind center, Likely has been an explosive spark and steady force in the Giants’ passing game.
Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Likely far and away leads the Giants with seven receiving touchdowns, and is second to Nabers in catches (55) and receiving yards (675) as a steady weapon and focal point of New York’s offense.
A testament to Likely’s consistency is the fact that regardless of who has been at the helm of the Giants’ offense, quarterbacks have combined for an elite 112.2 passer rating when targeting him.
Dangerous in the red zone, lethal after the catch, where he’s averaging 4.2 yards after the reception, Likely’s breakout has been a centerpiece to the Giants’ run to the division lead and might just be scratching the surface of the kind of weapon he has the potential to be.
Check out our NEW Between The Hashmarks Gear Shop, Including Activewear by Nike, and More!
Parker Washington, WR, Jacksonville Jaguars
It’s time to start believing in the Jacksonville Jaguars, and a big reason why the offense is surging is Parker Washington’s explosive dominance.
Washington has rendered 2024 first-round pick Brian Thomas Jr. irrelevant, he’s become Trevor Lawrence’s favorite target, and head coach Liam Coen’s personal gyuto, slicing up defenses weekly.
So far this season, Washington has caught 36 passes for 645 yards and six touchdowns, while averaging an astronomical 17.5 yards per reception, which easily leads the league among those with qualified targets.
The 5-foot-10 and 212-pound dynamo has been as dangerous after the catch as he has been making contested catches deep downfield. Pro Football Focus points out that Washington boasts an electrifying 13.1-yard average depth of target and Lawrence has produced an elite 121.3 passer rating when targeting him while he’s averaging a staggering 6.1 yards after the catch.
Jacksonville enters Week 11 ranked No. 5 in offensive DVOA, and Washington is a big reason why the Jaguars have been so efficient.
PODCAST
Dillon Thieneman, S, Chicago Bears
General manager Ryan Poles and the Chicago Bears identified a major weakness in the secondary this spring after safeties Jaquan Brisker and Kevin Byard departed in free agency, before drafting Dillon Thieneman in the first round of April’s NFL Draft.
In his rookie campaign, Thieneman has resoundingly made the Bears wonder, “Byard or Brisker, who?!”
Thieneman has been the working definition of an instant-impact player, leading the Bears in tackles with 57, he’s become a bit of a no-fly zone in deep coverage, where he’s intercepted one pass and broken up five more, and defensive coordinator Dennis Allen hasn’t shied away from sending the former Oregon standout on some exotic blitzes where he’s logged 1.5 sacks and 2.5 tackles for loss.
Allen has thrown his entire playbook at Thieneman, who has thrown his weight around all over the field quickly developing into a disruptive force in the middle of the Bears’ defense.
If Jeffery Simmons’ arrival has shown us anything it is that his impact is having a trickle on impact on all three levels of Chicago’s defense, and the chaos he’s able to create up front could create even more big-play opportunities for Thieneman as quarterbacks are pressed into dire mistakes under duress. Stay tuned.
Denzel Boston, WR, Cleveland Browns
The Cleveland Browns have been one of the NFL’s most stunning contenders, and Boston’s instant impact on offense has been a big reason why.
Only tight end Harold Fannin has caught more passes in the Browns’ offense than the rookie wide receiver has, with Boston pulling down 33 of his 62 targets for 523 yards and three touchdowns.
Boston’s big-play ability is on display each week, averaging not just 15.8 yards per reception but a 15.3-yard Average Depth of Target that ranks eighth among NFL receivers.
If nothing else, opposite fellow rookie KC Concepcion, the Browns have the foundation for a dynamic passing game for years to come, and with Boston, the kind of player capable of powering a postseason charge immediately.
Matthew Golden, WR, Green Bay Packers
Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-Imagn Images
Matthew Golden is so close to putting it all together and becoming the difference-making burner and elite wide receiver the Packers envisioned when they chose him in the first round, out of Texas, in the 2026 NFL Draft.
Golden’s speed is undeniable, and he’s one of the few players capable of taking the top off opposing secondaries with ease, as illustrated by his 14.1-yard Average Depth of Target on his way to averaging 14.7 yards per reception.
There’s no question that Packers quarterback Jordan Love trusts Golden explicitly, given that the six-foot-and-195-pound burner accounts for a whopping 27.4% of Love’s target share while catching a team-high 58 passes for 853 yards and five touchdowns.
However, for as much as Golden has come to define the explosive nature of the Packers’ offense, he also embodies the biggest concern that has plagued Green Bay for years, having dropped 11 passes so far this season, according to Pro Football Focus.
If Golden can figure out a way to put it all together, the Packers look close to unstoppable. Green Bay is 4-1 in games he catches at least one touchdown, but just 2-3 in games that he doesn’t.
So, there are few players outside of Love who are more vital to the Packers’ outlook than Golden.
Superstars will always command the spotlight. But come January, don't be surprised when one of these seven names, or players even more unheralded yet to emerge, are the ones who make the plays that swing a playoff game.


